Pugwash Online Search Pugwash
About Us Donate National Groups Reports Publications Contact Us Links Site Index Pugwash Conferences on Science and World Affairs


Pugwash Workshop

Science and International Humanitarian Law
Science to the Service of War and the Responsibility of Scientists
20-21 September 2005, Paris
More information: http://www.science-ihl.com/

Sponsors
ADIF, Association for the Defense of the International Humanitarian Fundamental Laws
Euroscience
Pugwash-France
Fondations Daniel Iagolnitzer and La Ferthé (under aegis of the Fondation de France)
UNESCO

Main organizers:
Daniel Iagolnitzer, physicist, president of the ADIF
Lydie Koch Miramond, physicist, president of the Commission of Human Rights of the French Physical Society and of the Working group on Ethics in Science of Euroscience

Agenda



Most scientists want science to serve as a source of knowledge and progress. However, we cannot forget that it has been used, and is still used today, in the service of war, thus becoming an indirect accessory to war crimes (violations of the International Humanitarian Law, as laid down in the Geneva conventions and additional treaties). Scientists are not directly responsible for this misuse of science, but can they avoid feeling implicated? The year 2005, International Year of Physicist in celebration of fundamental achievements of Albert Einstein in 1905, is also the 60th anniversary of the two atomic bombings, reproved by Einstein and other scientists, of civilian populations of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and the 50th anniversary of the Einstein-Russell Manifesto for disarmament.

The Symposium will recall some outstanding "feats" of science in the service of war in recent history and related current affairs, such as the atomic bombs in 1945, with in 2005 projects of "new nuclear weapons" on the one hand and new requests, under the impulse of the Mayor of Hiroshima, for the abolition of nuclear weapons on the other hand, or also the massive use of a chemical weapon (agent orange, containing dioxin) in Indochina during 10 years with its consequences, still present today, on the environment and population (illnesses, infant malformations,...) and the requests in 2005 for new scientific studies and compensation of victims. It will present the recent developments of sophisticated classical weapons (airplanes, missiles, bombs,...), their use in recent wars with for instance more than 100000 civilians killed in Irak according to an October 2004 report in "The Lancet", and new projects (militarization of space,...). The question of torture assisted by physicians and scientists will also be raised.

General agenda of the Symposium: plenary talks will present, in a precise and synthetic way, the historical and technical aspects of the different weapons, their use and prospects, the pertinent elements of the International Humanitarian Law and its violations. They will be followed by a Round Table where representatives of various groups of concerned scientists will present their views and activities and where the present situation and perspectives, as well as the attitudes and responsibility of scientists and their Institutions, will be widely discussed.

Tentative contents and schedule

1. The International Humanitarian Law: introduction and basic aspects linked to the use of science (9.00-9.30)

2. Nuclear weapons (9.30-11.00)

- Hiroshima-Nagasaki. Was the use of atomic weapons justified? The attitude of scientists
- the development of nuclear weapons since 1945 and the Non Proliferation Treaty; its article VI and its (non) application; current claims for its application
- current projects of "new nuclear weapons"
- how science can contribute in practice to nuclear disarmament

3. Chemical and Bacteriological weapons (11.30-12.45)

- the use of these weapons in the 20th century
- the agent orange; present scientific estimates of its consequences, current claims for compensation of civilian victims
- conventions on the prohibition of their production and use and on their destruction
- present situation and perspectives

4. Classical weapons and various projects (14.15-15.45)

- new classical weapons (planes, missiles, bombs,...)
- their use in recent wars
- new projects (weapons in space,...) and perspectives
- the international arms trade

5. "Scientific" or "medicalized" torture (15.45-16.15)

6. Round Table: perspectives and the responsibility of scientists and their Institutions (16.30-18.30)

- presentation of the activities of various groups of concerned scientists
discussion